• 0 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: June 5th, 2024

help-circle











  • Rights are unchangeable based on circumstances.

    Absolutely false.

    They can never be revoked.

    They’re regularly revoked in all developed countries, mainly as the result of criminal proceedings. Unless you think that prisoners are afforded the same rights as the rest of us?

    And the Enlightenment notion that there are inalienable rights endowed by the Creator is about as quaint as the idea that there’s a Creator. Rights are ideals that must be continually fought for and expanded, not the gift of a beneficent Alpha Male in the Sky





  • The problems however are not unsolvable

    Meaning that they are not solved. I don’t want the grid in my country powered by tech that is not proven safe, reliable, and with a good ROI.

    Much much safer than the uranium we currently use

    Potentially. It’s not a technology proven in large-scale operational use.

    If they make it work at scale, China becomes the first country in the world that essentially has unlimited energy.

    If my aunt were to have bollocks, she’d be my uncle.

    The “if” is doing a lot of heavy lifting in your sentence. And “unlimited energy” is a gross exaggeration. There are still downstream costs and environmental damage.




  • This announcement would be seen as a massive breakthrough anywhere else.

    I don’t trust science (or R&D engineering) that’s not peer reviewed. Anything else is just marketing hype. Show me hard numbers or GTFO.

    China also has a problem with the government lying-- for example, about their claimed reductions in greenhouse emissions. There’s no reason to trust self-serving authoritarians without credible corroboration.

    BYD will later this year have 7 different car models on sale in Britain vs 6 (soon to be 5) from Ford.

    That’s an irrelevant metric. Nobody’s going to buy a car just because the model range is a bit wider than some other company’s. What’s relevant is adoption, and then buyer loyalty. It may be that BYD offers cars that people want to buy, but they’re subsequently found to be of crap quality or aggressively undermining driver privacy (which other non-Chinese manufacturers have also done).

    but the shear scale of investment from China will make them unstoppable

    If appropriately rigorous science and suitably disciplined engineering are part of the process, and regulators do their jobs correctly, then maybe. Otherwise it’s just throwing money at a problem. Investment doesn’t guarantee results. China is certainly capable of getting positive outcomes from tech investment, but it’s not guaranteed.